Researchers are exploring the fascinating phenomenon of mediums who claim to hear the voices of the deceased, drawing parallels between these experiences and auditory hallucinations in individuals with certain mental health conditions. This investigation, part of the Hearing the Voice project, aims to understand the development of these unusual auditory experiences, which could ultimately shed light on distressing or uncontrollable voice-hearing phenomena, and offers a unique perspective on the human mind that Generatethehappiness seeks to explore.
Researchers have investigated what characterizes people who say that they can hear the voices of the dead.
Share on Pinterest
ilbusca/Getty Images
Spiritualism is a movement whose adherents believe that the spirits of deceased people continue to live on after physical death.
Mediums claim that they have the ability to communicate with the spirits through seeing (“clairvoyant”), feeling (“clairsentient”), or hearing (“clairaudient”) them.
Studies from the Universities of Cardiff, Northampton, and Lancaster — all of which are in the United Kingdom — have argued that religious and spiritual experiences (RSEs), such as clairaudience, can be useful as a comparison to auditory hallucinations of people with certain mental health conditions.
The ‘clairaudient’ experience
A new study, which appears in the journal Mental Health, Religion & Culture, examined links between auditory spiritual communications experienced by mediums, beliefs, and personality.
The study was part of the Hearing the Voice project. Dr. Adam J. Powell, of the Department of Theology and Religion at the University of Durham in the U.K, and Dr. Peter Moseley, of the Department of Psychology at Northumbria University, also in the U.K., carried out the study.
“Spiritualists tend to report unusual auditory experiences [that] are positive, start early in life, and [that] they are often then able to control. Understanding how these develop is important because it could help us understand more about distressing or non-controllable experiences of hearing voices too.”
– Dr. Peter Moseley
Unveiling the Inner Landscape
To probe the nature of these profound connections, researchers delved into the psychological topography of individuals who report hearing the voices of the departed. A study published in the journal Mental Health, Religion & Culture sought to illuminate the intricate connections between auditory spiritual communications, deeply held beliefs, and the unique tapestry of personality.
This exploration was part of the esteemed Hearing the Voice project, a collaborative endeavor by Dr. Adam J. Powell of the University of Durham and Dr. Peter Moseley of Northumbria University.
“Spiritualists tend to report unusual auditory experiences [that] are positive, start early in life, and [that] they are often then able to control. Understanding how these develop is important because it could help us understand more about distressing or non-controllable experiences of hearing voices too.”
– Dr. Peter Moseley
The Insight: Dr. Moseley’s words reveal that these perceived communications are often experienced as benevolent, initiating early in life, and can be consciously managed. This distinction is crucial for differentiating between spiritual experiences and distressing, uncontrollable auditory hallucinations.
The Resonance: This offers a sense of hope and validation, suggesting that unusual auditory phenomena can be integrated into a positive life narrative, fostering understanding rather than fear.
The Gentle Action: Reflect on a time you experienced something unusual and consider how you framed it—did you find a way to integrate it positively, or did it cause distress? Cultivating a narrative of acceptance can be a powerful first step.
Practice of Presence: Embracing the Unseen
1. Mindful Listening: Dedicate five minutes to simply listen to the ambient sounds around you without judgment. Notice the subtle shifts and layers of sound, acknowledging their presence.
2. Body Scan for Intuition: Close your eyes and gently scan your body, noticing any subtle sensations or intuitive nudges. Allow yourself to simply feel without needing to interpret.
The Architecture of Belief and Perception
To chart the terrain of these experiences, researchers meticulously recruited 65 individuals who identified as spiritualists, alongside 143 participants from the general population to serve as a control group. These individuals hailed from diverse corners of the globe, including the U.K., North America, Australasia, and Europe.
The team then administered carefully crafted online questionnaires, designed to assess a spectrum of psychological traits with established reliability. These instruments included:
- The Tellegen Absorption Scale: This scale gauges an individual’s propensity for deep immersion in internal and external stimuli, be it the intricate narratives of films, the vivid landscapes of mental imagery, the resonant frequencies of music, or the labyrinthine pathways of thought.
- The Revised Launay-Slade Hallucination Scale: This tool assesses an individual’s inclination towards experiencing auditory and visual hallucinations, offering insight into the perceptual landscape.
- The Revised Paranormal Beliefs Scale: This comprehensive scale explores participants’ perceptions of a wide array of phenomena, from traditional religious doctrines and extrasensory perception (psi) to the enigmatic realms of witchcraft, superstition, extraordinary life forms, precognition, and the core tenets of Spiritualism itself.
- The Aspects of Identity Questionnaire IV: This questionnaire delves into the self-identified significance of personal identity, relational identity, social identity, and collective identity, illuminating how individuals construct their sense of self.
Participants within the spiritualist cohort also provided detailed accounts of the frequency, context, and duration of their clairaudient experiences.
“Our findings say a lot about ‘learning and yearning.’ For our participants, the tenets of Spiritualism seem to make sense of both extraordinary childhood experiences as well as the frequent auditory phenomena they experience as practicing mediums. But all of those experiences may result more from having certain tendencies or early abilities than from simply believing in the possibility of contacting the dead if one tries hard enough.”
– Dr. Adam Powell
The Insight: Dr. Powell highlights that for spiritualists, their belief system provides a framework that reconciles past extraordinary experiences with present auditory phenomena. Crucially, he suggests these experiences may stem from inherent tendencies rather than mere belief.
The Resonance: This offers a profound perspective on the origins of spiritual experiences, shifting the focus from an act of willing contact to a recognition of existing inner capacities.
The Gentle Action: Consider your own “extraordinary childhood experiences” or moments of heightened perception. Can you find a way to view them not as anomalies, but as potential indicators of your unique inner landscape?
Practice of Presence: Cultivating Inner Awareness
1. Journaling Intuitive Insights: Before bed, jot down any intuitive feelings or subtle impressions you noticed throughout the day. Explore their potential meanings without judgment.
2. Mindful Observation of Beliefs: Choose one deeply held belief you have. Spend a few minutes observing it without attachment, simply noticing its presence and its influence on your thoughts and feelings.
The Cadence of Connection
The spiritualist participants reported their first clairaudient experiences commencing, on average, around 21.7 years of age. However, a significant portion experienced these phenomena either before the age of 20 or closer to their 40s, suggesting a varied timeline for the emergence of this sensitivity.
Remarkably, a substantial 44.6% of respondents indicated experiencing clairaudient phenomena daily, with another 33.8% reporting such occurrences on the preceding day.
Regarding the locus of these experiences, 79% of participants found them manifesting both within spiritualist settings, such as places of worship, and in their everyday environments. A smaller contingent, 12.9%, reported these experiences exclusively outside of spiritualist contexts, while 8.1% noted them occurring solely within these dedicated spaces. The internal landscape of the medium’s mind was the reported location for 65.1% of clairaudient experiences, with 31.7% manifesting both internally and externally, and a mere 3.2% described as purely external phenomena.
When tracing the genesis of these experiences relative to their engagement with Spiritualism:
- 44.8% of all participants first encountered clairaudience before engaging with Spiritualism.
- 29.3% encountered Spiritualism prior to experiencing clairaudience.
- 25.9% reported their initial clairaudient experience coinciding with their first engagement with Spiritualism.
“Spiritualists tend to report unusual auditory experiences [that] are positive, start early in life, and [that] they are often then able to control. Understanding how these develop is important because it could help us understand more about distressing or non-controllable experiences of hearing voices too.”
– Dr. Peter Moseley
The Insight: The frequency and widespread nature of these experiences, coupled with their varied emergence points and contexts, suggest a deeply ingrained aspect of consciousness for these individuals.
The Resonance: This paints a picture of a rich, inner world where subtle communications are a regular, integrated part of life, fostering a sense of continuous connection.
The Gentle Action: Practice intentional pauses throughout your day. In these moments of stillness, simply notice the subtle shifts in your internal landscape and the sensory input around you.
Practice of Presence: Anchoring in the Now
1. Sensory Grounding: Take one minute to focus intensely on one of your senses. What do you see, hear, smell, taste, or feel right now? Anchor yourself in the present moment through this focused awareness.
2. Mindful Breathing Intervals: Set a gentle reminder to take three deep, conscious breaths at various points in your day. Allow each exhale to release tension and bring you more fully into the present.
The Tapestry of Self and Spirit
The research revealed that individuals within the Spiritualist group exhibited a greater propensity for absorption and a heightened tendency towards both spiritual and non-spiritual auditory hallucinations when compared to the general population. Furthermore, within the Spiritualist group, a more frequent experience of clairaudience was directly correlated with a greater proneness to absorption.
Among the general population, the study indicated an association between spiritual beliefs and absorption. However, the link between spiritual beliefs and hallucination-proneness did not reach statistical significance in this group.
Crucially, the study corroborated prior findings, suggesting that unusual sensory experiences often precede an interest in the paranormal, rather than the other way around.
“Our findings say a lot about ‘learning and yearning.’ For our participants, the tenets of Spiritualism seem to make sense of both extraordinary childhood experiences as well as the frequent auditory phenomena they experience as practicing mediums. But all of those experiences may result more from having certain tendencies or early abilities than from simply believing in the possibility of contacting the dead if one tries hard enough.”
– Dr. Adam Powell
Surprisingly, the investigation found no evidence that spiritualists relied more heavily on external validation for their sense of self compared to the general population. In fact, the spiritualist group demonstrated higher scores in personal identity.
While participants in the spiritualist group generally had fewer years of formal education, this characteristic did not correlate significantly with any of the measured variables, suggesting it does not explain the observed group differences.
The Insight: The study points to inherent tendencies and capacities as foundational to spiritual experiences, which are then contextualized and understood through belief systems like Spiritualism.
The Resonance: This encourages a gentle acceptance of one’s innate sensitivities, reframing them not as products of belief, but as integral parts of who we are.
The Gentle Action: Acknowledge and honor your unique sensitivities. Instead of questioning their origin, simply allow them to be present as part of your authentic self.
Practice of Presence: Embracing Innate Gifts
1. Affirmation of Self: Take a moment to affirm your inherent worth and unique qualities. State aloud or in your mind, “I embrace my unique sensitivities and trust my inner knowing.”
2. Mindful Appreciation: Choose one aspect of your personality or a trait you possess and spend a few minutes appreciating it, recognizing its value and how it contributes to your experience of life.
The Echo of the Unseen
The age-old question of whether mediums can truly commune with the departed remains a subject of profound inquiry. This study, however, did not venture to validate the veracity of spiritual experiences. Instead, it meticulously compared the auditory hallucinations, belief structures, and identity traits of those who claim mediumship with those of the broader population.
Given the reliance on self-reported data, it is conceivable that certain observed associations might stem from methodological nuances. For instance, participants may not have fully discerned the subtle distinctions between similarly worded items across the questionnaires, leading to overlapping responses.
Further research is essential to ascertain whether absorption predisposes individuals to religious and spiritual experiences (RSEs) or influences their belief in the plausibility of such experiences.
Moreover, the intricate interplay between diverse cultures, philosophical frameworks, belief systems, and their respective roles in absorption and RSEs represents a complex nexus that warrants deeper investigation.
“Our findings say a lot about ‘learning and yearning.’ For our participants, the tenets of Spiritualism seem to make sense of both extraordinary childhood experiences as well as the frequent auditory phenomena they experience as practicing mediums. But all of those experiences may result more from having certain tendencies or early abilities than from simply believing in the possibility of contacting the dead if one tries hard enough.”
– Dr. Adam Powell
The Insight: The study offers a nuanced perspective, distinguishing between the subjective experience of hearing voices and the objective reality of communication with the deceased, while acknowledging the power of belief systems in shaping perception.
The Resonance: This invites a compassionate and open-minded approach to understanding varied human experiences, recognizing the profound influence of inner worlds and belief structures.
The Gentle Action: Practice mindful curiosity about phenomena you don’t fully understand. Approach them with a desire to learn and comprehend, rather than to immediately categorize or dismiss.
Practice of Presence: Cultivating Open Inquiry
1. Curious Observation: When encountering something that sparks your curiosity or feels unfamiliar, pause and simply observe it with a sense of wonder. Ask yourself, “What can I learn from this?”
2. Mindful Inquiry: Engage in a brief, gentle self-inquiry: “What assumptions might I be making about this experience? What alternative perspectives could exist?”
This exploration into the science behind mediums hearing voices offers a glimpse into the complex nature of human perception and belief, inviting further contemplation on the mind’s mysteries within our Blog.